Weeknotes

Emily Macaulay

Emily Macaulay

Emily Macaulay

What I’ve been doing

I had a good run of writing up weekly week notes, and now a month has slipped by so I’m making the effort to get these done.

The past few weeks have been a whirlwind of supporting the logistics for our People’s Panel on AI. There’s so much to reflect on that alone that I will do separately (hopefully next week).

Of course this has meant (the Panel and the UK’s AI Safety Summit taking place this week) that there is a lot of talk (internally and externally) about AI. My work in CONNECTED BY DATA, and some freelance work I’m doing to promote inclusivity, both have a strong centre around narratives - storytelling. Who is doing the telling? Why? What are the words used? And how is the story being passed on? AI is a really clear current narrative in our public media and more generally in popular culture.

Image of film poster with an image of a human face with a robotic head and text that reads "created to save us" but the word save is crossed out in blood and replaced with "destroy".

Waiting at a train station recently I was confronted with this film poster - literally a story about AI being created for apparently good but actually to destroy us. When this is the predominant backdrop - reinforced by the UK Government’s Summit focussing entirely on existential “frontier” risk of AI (is it / isn’t it going to kill us all) - how can we hope to engage people in conversations about the real life impacts it is having in our world now (you can read about some of those in a piece of work our Adam is doing with the TUC).

On a lighter note…I also saw this in a hotel I stayed in recently. I couldn’t decide if it was warning me simply so I didn’t trip over it or because it was out to get me! And either way I imagine if I hadn’t come across a robot cleaner before this may have unnerved me somewhat.

Image of yellow floor sign that reads "caution robotoic cleaners in operation".

What I need to take care of

There’s a lot of wrap up actions around the People’s Panel both in terms of finances (including balancing budgets) and reflecting / sharing lessons learned (individually and collectively).

Then AI continues to dominate and focus switches to supporting the delivery of our next Design Lab - this one a three day residential in Stroud - where attendees will be exploring and co-creating Resources for Effective & Inclusive Public Deliberation on Data & AI Governance.

What I’ve been inspired or challenged or moved by

It was a few weeks ago now that I first saw this video but I’m still loving it. I wouldn’t read Apple’s sustainability report. I would possibly glance at a news outlets headline surfacing one key fact. But I watched this from start to finish, undistracted, and in addition to applauding their delivery of this message (and hurrah for Octavia Spencer!) - actually feel hopeful that they’re having an impact in the fight against our climate crisis.

What I’ve been reading

I attended our recent Connected Conversation on ‘collective data rights’ (write up available here) which reminded me of these articles I’d read about collective redress: Martin Tisne writing about when harm is collective, so must rights be; and IFoW writing about regulation of algorithmic management. This concept of collective - and how a group that may not know they are a group, or that they’ve been impact by “invisible” algorithms, can find each other, come together and then “take on” a (probably strong institution / tech company) seems a real power imbalance to me. From my lay person, public culturist, perspective I’m reminded of the film Erin Brokovich and how hard her fight was - and that was when the evidence was clearly identifiable, in a defined area, and visibly traceable. If that was data - or AI - caused, I wonder what needs to happen to make that redress easier (which in turn will change future policy and governance).

Do you collect, use or share data?

We can help you build trust with your customers, clients or citizens

 Read more

Do you want data to be used in your community’s interests?

We can help you organise to ensure that data benefits your community

 Read more